Every Noun
- 30 min
- Hook 3
- Reading 7
- Discussion 8
- Exercise 10
- Challenge setup 2
Objectives
By the end of this session you can:
- Explain the difference between agency and intelligence in your own words, with one example from your own life.
- Name which low-agency belief shows up most for you, and in what situations.
- Record a baseline score on the 10 behaviors in your journal.
Hook: The Noun Hunt (3 min)
Look around the room you're in. Pick five objects: the chair, the charger, the light switch, the app you last opened, the paint color on the wall. For each one, say out loud: "A person decided this should exist."
Now pick one and guess: what did that person have to figure out that nobody had taught them?
Hold that thought. Someone famous said almost exactly this, and you're about to read it.
Reading: Agency > Intelligence (7 min)
In February 2025, Andrej Karpathy, a co-founder of OpenAI who used to run AI at Tesla, posted something surprising coming from a person known mostly for being brilliant:
"Agency > Intelligence. I had this intuitively wrong for decades… Agency is significantly more powerful and significantly more scarce. Are you hiring for agency? Are we educating for agency? Are you acting as if you had 10X agency?"
Are we educating for agency? Mostly, no. School rewards a different skill. Someone hands you a clear task, a rubric, and a due date, and you execute. You're good at that. It's a real skill. It's also the skill AI got cheap at first.
Agency is what happens when there's no assignment. Something is broken, missing, or could be much better, and you decide it's yours to act on. You don't wait for a teacher, a tutorial, or someone's blessing. You find a way.
Mitchell Hashimoto, co-founder of the software company HashiCorp, said it in September 2026:
"I can't stress enough how little an idea matters compared to the agency of the people executing the idea… The difference between mediocre and excellent work and outcomes is predominantly one of agency… They don't wait for someone else to do something, for someone to teach them, for someone to give them the path… They just go out and find a way to do it… Look around the room you're sitting in… Every noun. It almost all exists because a person willed it into existence. Nothing is stopping you from doing the same."
George Mack, who wrote an essay called High Agency, boils it down to two triangles of beliefs:
| High Agency Triangle | Low Agency Triangle |
|---|---|
| "I will figure it out." | "I don't know what to do." |
| "I am willing to be misunderstood." | "I'm afraid of what people will think." |
| "I can fix it if it breaks." | "I'm afraid of the action going wrong." |
Look closely at the low triangle. None of it is about being dumb or lazy. It's all uncertainty and fear. Smart people live there constantly, sometimes more than anyone, because they're used to knowing the answer before they start.
Two things to clear up now. Agency has nothing to do with being loud, grinding until 2 a.m., or acting like the main character. Some of the highest-agency people you'll ever meet are quiet. And real agency includes judgment: knowing when to ask first, and owning it when you get it wrong. You'll practice both.
Agency is a behavior, which means it's trainable. You'll train it the only way that works: by doing things nobody asked you to do and seeing what happens.
Discussion (8 min)
Pick three.
- Think of someone you actually know (not a celebrity) who has high agency. What did they do that made you notice?
- Karpathy says agency is "more scarce" than intelligence. What in your normal week trains intelligence? What, if anything, trains agency?
- Which low-agency belief is loudest for you? Is it the same at school, with friends, and online?
- Pushback: "Nothing is stopping you" sounds great, but plenty of people lack money, time, connections, or safety. Is Hashimoto's line true? Write the most honest version of it you'd actually believe.
- When is "I will figure it out" the wrong attitude?
Exercise: Baseline + Stuck List (10 min)
- Baseline (4 min). Open your Reflection Journal and score yourself 1–5 on all 10 behaviors in the "Before" column. Be honest; nobody grades this.
-
Stuck List (6 min). Write three things you've wanted to do, make, or change for more than a month and haven't. Next to each, tag the belief that's holding it:
- D = "I don't know what to do"
- P = "I'm afraid of what people will think"
- W = "I'm afraid it'll go wrong"
Circle one. Write the smallest first step that would take under 15 minutes. You don't have to do it yet. Seeing how small it is usually does something.
Challenge: The Unasked Fix (30–60 min, before Session 2)
Find something at home that's been broken, annoying, or undone for at least a month, that nobody has asked you to fix. Fix it.
Ideas: the drawer that won't close, the remote that needs batteries, the family calendar chaos, the photo backup nobody set up, the Wi-Fi that dies in one room, the junk drawer, the bike with the flat tire.
Rules:
- Don't announce it first. Don't ask anyone how. Figure it out (search, video, AI, trial and error).
- Once it's done, tell the person it affects in one sentence.
Done when:
Stretch: Fix something outside your house: the team equipment bag, a broken link on your club's page, the lost-and-found. If it isn't yours, get the owner's OK first.
Safety: Nothing electrical beyond batteries and plugging things in. No tools you haven't used before without an adult nearby. No spending money without asking.
Journal
- What were you telling yourself in the 10 seconds before you started the fix?
- Which point of the high-agency triangle did you use? Which one was missing?
- How much did you actually need help, compared with how much you thought you would?